Buffalo vs. Rochester: Which Western NY Metro Scores Higher?

Buffalo and Rochester sit seventy miles apart along the New York State Thruway. While both regions share Upstate New York economic roots and affordable housing, their suburban school districts and housing prices reflect different local trajectories.

Comparing Buffalo and Rochester ZIP codes

Scores evaluate communities against New York state medians. Academic metrics draw from the National Center for Education Statistics, and housing values come from county deed files.

1. Rochester Brighton (14618): Scores 62 overall with an 82 school score, 45 crime score, and a median home price of $409,665.
2. Buffalo Amherst (14226): Scores 59 overall with a 74 school score, 45 crime score, and a median home price of $319,359.
3. Rochester Irondequoit (14617): Scores 60 overall with a 76 school score, 45 crime score, and a median home price of $269,781.
4. Buffalo Cheektowaga (14227): Scores 58 overall with a 73 school score, 45 crime score, and a median home price of $273,030.

Taxes and suburban school quality in Western New York

Both Erie and Monroe counties feature independent suburban school districts that post graduation rates above 90 percent. U.S. Census Bureau data indicates that housing costs remain manageable across both metros relative to Downstate New York.

Comparing Western New York communities

Movers can compare Buffalo and Rochester ZIP codes on our New York comparison tool or consult our neighborhood research guide.