NEIGHBORSCORE

Surprise, New York · ZIP 12176

Surprise Crime Statistics

OverviewCrime DataSchools

Overall ScoreiWeighted average of two sub-scores: Crime & Safety (53%) and Schools (47%). Affordability is shown as context and is not weighted into the overall.

82OUT OF 100

Good

Crime & SafetyiBased on the best available local, FBI agency, county, or state-remainder reported-crime tier. Higher scores mean a lower reported rate relative to the applicable benchmark.

95

95/100

Excellent

SchoolsiBased on reported math and reading proficiency plus grade-band coverage. Nearby or county-level estimates are used when ZIP-level reporting is sparse; if no proficiency signal is available, the score is limited to grade-band coverage.

67

67/100

Fair

AffordabilityiHow the available home value or price metric compares within the state — a higher score means more affordable, lower means pricier. It is context only.

48

48/100

Mid-Market

Nearby Neighborhoods

Earlton, New YorkEarltonZIP 12058
82= even vs here
Greenville, New YorkGreenvilleZIP 12083
46▼36 vs here
Freehold, New YorkFreeholdZIP 12431
82= even vs here
Leeds, New YorkLeedsZIP 12451
82= even vs here

2025 Annual Summary

Total Incidents

159

Violent Crime

25

Property Crime

134

Crime statistics for this area are estimated from FBI-reported county-level data for Greene County, New York (2025). This ZIP does not yet have city-specific monthly crime data, so figures reflect the entire county rather than this ZIP alone.

About This Data

The summary shown for Surprise (ZIP 12176) uses annual county-level reporting from the FBI Crime Data Explorer/UCR program. It reflects crimes reported by participating law-enforcement agencies; coverage and reporting systems vary by agency and year.

The crime score of 95/100 uses the best available city, agency, county, or state-remainder tier and its applicable benchmark. A higher score represents a lower reported rate under that tier; it is not a guarantee of safety.