NEIGHBORSCORE

Shelter Island, New York · ZIP 11964

Shelter Island — ZIP 11964

Crime DataSchools

Shelter Island (11964) scores 75/100 — Good for Shelter Island. Safety: Lower reported-crime rate under the available data tier. Schools: Mid-range proficiency and grade-band coverage. A premium market - pricier than most of the state. The typical home value here is $1.81M.

75OUT OF 100

Overall NeighborScore

BGood

Tap a tab to compare 11964 against its city, state, or the nation.

Lower reported-crime rate under the available data tier.

Safety index95/100
Violent crime share7%
Property crime share93%

Mid-range proficiency and grade-band coverage.

School index52/100
Avg math proficiency32%
Avg reading proficiency52%
Schools nearby1

A premium market - pricier than most of the state.

Affordability index13/100
Typical home value$1.81M

How this score is calculated: the NeighborScore composite weights crime 53% and schools 47%, each normalized to the local area. Home affordability is shown for context and is not factored into the overall score. Sources & methodology →

Last refreshed — Schools: Aug 2026 · Real estate: Aug 2026 · Demographics: Jun 2026

Nearby Neighborhoods

Not the right fit? See how adjacent ZIPs score — tap to jump over.

Shelter Island, New YorkShelter IslandZIP 11965
81▲6 vs here
Greenport, New YorkGreenportZIP 11944
75= even vs here
East Marion, New YorkEast MarionZIP 11939
79▲4 vs here
Southold, New YorkSoutholdZIP 11971
81▲6 vs here

More ZIPs in Shelter Island

Shelter Island, New YorkShelter IslandZIP 11965
81▲6 vs here

Real Estate Snapshot

Typical Home Value

$1.81M

Median Rent

—

Days on Market

—

Sale-to-List

—

Typical Home Value — 23 Months

Crime Overview

Total Incidents

1,929

Violent Crime

141

Property Crime

1,788

Crime statistics for this area are estimated from FBI-reported county-level data for Suffolk County, New York (2025). This ZIP does not yet have city-specific monthly crime data, so figures reflect the entire county rather than this ZIP alone.

Full Crime Report →

Nearby Schools

Grades
SHELTER ISLAND SCHOOLPK–12183
32%
52%

Directory and latest enrollment: NCES Common Core of Data (SY 2024–25 where reported). Proficiency: U.S. Department of Education EDFacts SY 2021–22; state standards are not directly comparable.

Full School Report →

Demographics

Population

2,858

Median Income

$135K

Homeownership

93%

Median Age

43.6 yrs

Source: US Census Bureau ACS 5-Year Estimates (2024).

Map

Frequently Asked Questions

ZIP 11964 has a reported-crime score of 95/100. A higher score represents a lower reported-crime rate under the best available data tier for this ZIP; it is not a guarantee of safety. Review the crime report and current local police data before making a decision.
ZIP 11964 has a school score of 52/100. The index combines reported SY 2021–22 math and reading proficiency with grade-band coverage. Nearby or county-level estimates may be used where ZIP-level reporting is sparse, and state assessment standards are not directly comparable.
The latest home value or sale-price figure available for ZIP 11964 is approximately $1.81M. The profile identifies the underlying source; Zillow ZHVI is a typical home value measure, while Redfin data is a median sale-price measure. These are different metrics and may lag current listings.
ZIP 11964 in Shelter Island has an overall NeighborScore of 75/100. It combines the crime score (53%) and school score (47%); affordability is context only. Use the component data and its coverage notes rather than treating the composite as a complete measure of livability.