NEIGHBORSCORE

Shelter Island, NY · ZIP 11964

Shelter Island

Crime DataSchoolsReal Estate

Overall Score

48OUT OF 100

Below Average

Crime & Safety

50

50/100

Fair

Schools

70

70/100

Good

Property Value

15

15/100

Below Average

Real Estate Snapshot

Median Price

$1.70M

Median Rent

—

Days on Market

—

Sale-to-List

—

Median Home Price — 24 Months

Median Rent — 24 Months

Full Market Report →

Crime Overview

Monthly Incidents — -Infinity

Year-over-Year

Full Crime Report →

Nearby Schools

SchoolGradesStudentsMath ↓Reading
SHELTER ISLAND SCHOOLPK–12———

Source: National Center for Education Statistics (NCES). Proficiency = % of students meeting state standards.

Full School Report →

Demographics

Population

2,858

Median Income

—

Homeownership

—

Median Age

—

Source: US Census Bureau ACS 5-Year Estimates (2024).

Map

Frequently Asked Questions

11964 (Shelter Island) has a crime score of 50/100 based on publicly reported incidents. Crime rates are roughly average for the region.

Nearby Neighborhoods

Shelter Island, NYShelter IslandZIP 11965
0Below Average